Larry McMurtry Update … Those Berrybenders are Back!

Today, I took a trip to Barnes & Noble to make use of the gift card I got for Christmas.

When I walked in the door, among the “new arrivals” was an extremely thick volume that had just hit the shelves by Larry McMurtry …

No, not a much appreciated re-issue in hardback of the book that made him famous, but a compilation of some of his weakest work ever, entitled “The Berrybender Narratives”

Yes, that’s correct.

One book.

With 1,500+ pages.

Priced at $37.50 USD!

And, devoted to … combining the four individually awful books that were already published earlier, each costing around $25 bucks apiece.

I suppose you could almost have predicted that this would happen. There was absolutely no reason for the four original volumes to have been published separately. In fact, I maintain that they were so uniformly bad, that there was little justification for publishing them at all.

A short while back, I wrote a blog giving my impressions of the direction McMurtry, one of my favorite authors, has taken since hitting the literary jackpot by writing “Lonesome Dove” … my all-time favorite novel! Here, he created an epic tale that painted a huge story on an immense canvas, populated by some of the most well-developed and interesting characters ever conceived.

Of course, he’d had successful efforts prior to this. For instance, his “Last Picture Show” was a very popular novel and proved to be an extremely successful movie when it was filmed in the late 70s, as was “Terms of Endearment” later in the 80s.

But, it’s hard to argue that he really hit his stride when he conjured up the vibrant characters of aging Texas Rangers Augustus McRae and Woodrow Call, and set them in motion through the glorious “Lonesome Dove” saga and subsequent sequels and prequels.

For me, there has been no greater piece of modern fiction and no finer film adaptation than this masterpiece.

So, it troubled me to report that in the decades following his best effort, McMurtry seems to have fallen victim to the curse that has afflicted other hugely successful fiction writers like John Grisham and Stephen King, etc.

McMurtry appears to have either consciously or subconsciously decided to rest on his laurels.

Individually, each Berrybender Narrative proved worse than the one that preceded it. For a fan of McMurtry, getting through these shorter stories was difficult, but achievable when taken in smaller doses with the forlorn hope that it would get better if I just gave it time.

In the form of this one huge tome, I fear the task will prove unbearable even for the most dedicated McMurtry disciple.

About Judson

Late bloomer ... aspiring writer and musician.
This entry was posted in books, Movies and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Larry McMurtry Update … Those Berrybenders are Back!

  1. territerri says:

    But did you find something else that you REALLY wanted to read?

    I LOVE Barnes & Noble. I could wander the place for hours.

    • Judson says:

      Yes … I bought a really nice “coffee table” photo book on Martin guitars! Found it on the bargain rack šŸ™‚

      For novels, I’ve been using the library instead of spending cash on “pigs in pokes” … If I see a book get rave reviews, I may buy it, but unbelievably, “The Berrybender Narratives” has a sizable number of fans, so who can I trust??

  2. nrhatch says:

    Glad you found something you liked . . . on the bargain rack, no less!

    I’m with you on novels, I borrow them from the library and give them back when I’m done.

  3. I love the berrybender and if Hollywood ever decided to bring them to life, im sure America would too. the events are endearing and outrageous. no one would have been particularly moved by lonesome dove had not Hollywood been able to set paper pages to brilliant screen. the story needs to be brought to life. you would see folks loving it

    • Judson says:

      I have to say that I read “Lonesome Dove” several years before it was made into the mini-series and found it one of the most entertaining books I have read. I thought the mini-series was brilliantly cast and true to the story, so it was great as well. Maybe “The Berrybender’s” could benefit from a good cinematic treatment. I don’t know. I totally agree that the stories and the characters were outrageous, but I never found them particularly endearing. To each his own, however. Cheers!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s